Friday, November 15, 2013

Patrick Jane: Multifaceted, Pathological, Genius


The character Patrick Jane has a very high IQ and exceptional natural abilities. His early training in deceptive arts, manipulation, sleight of hand, gambling, and criminal skills allowed these natural abilities to be fully developed. A lack of exposure to basic morality and moral norms, and also a lack of unconditional love, contributed to his criminal achievements as well as his pathology. But Jane is not a pure criminal. Jane is attracted to and clearly fascinated by lack of guile (as exemplified by children) and integrity (modeled by Lisbon and other cops, mostly).  

Jane has a pathological ability to con, trick and even kill (with little to no hesitation) anyone he perceives as being morally corrupt. This propensity is mitigated by the fact that he holds his own amoral behavior to the same standards. He is not himself immune to his own contempt. But he increasingly he shows he is capable of positive emotions such as love, respect, guilt, and personal responsibility, and can act according to those higher principles.

Mathematical

Jane clearly has a highly developed natural math ability, as well as extensive self-training in probability, as both a con man and as a gambler. He seems able to mentally calculate probabilities related to intuitive guesses, and he has an unusually low threshold for statistics-based decision making. While scientists generally have an extremely high margin for error, Jane seems quite willing to wager quite a lot on a very slim margin. Another characteristic of his mathematical skill is his ability to manage bias. While normal people may suffer from bias due to “anchoring” and “framing” effects, Jane seems very resistant to this and as a result improves the accuracy of his mathematical estimations.

Memory

Jane has a good memory, which he has honed using memorization techniques (Memory Palace), but he does not appear to have a photographic memory. This is probably a good thing since photographic memory is rare, of usually limited range, and can be associated with defects in the abstract processing or social abilities (which for Jane are if anything, heightened). Although he seems to have a very limited formal education (did not even attend high school) he is an autodidact and is never without reading material.

Observation

Jane has an unusually high ability to recognize and decode the most subtle human behaviors related to internal emotional states. He probably has a strong natural ability to do this, which was refined by his practice as a con man specializing as a psychic and as a carnival “mind” reader. In the show it is revealed that as a teenager in the carnival he spent time looking a people and practicing his observational abilities. He also honed his “mind-reading” skills using “probe” techniques. He often asks seemingly silly questions, invades people’s personal space, and uses other means to throw people off guard to elicit more telling reactions. He uses his skills at misdirection to pick their pockets as well as their mind, revealing important clues.

Manipulation

As mentioned, Jane uses his skills as a close-work magician, namely misdirection and sleight of hand and pocket picking, to reveal hidden clues. He also is an accomplished actor and often uses that skill to manipulate people’s trust to make them reveal more about their intentions than they would otherwise. He uses his personal charm and good looks to great effect as well. He is not shy about acting silly or ridiculous or even vulnerable to make himself appear harmless and unthreatening, which induces others to be more revealing.

Most dramatically, Jane seems to have an unusually high ability as a hypnotist, which he uses on occasion, even apparently without his subject’s consent, to get them to lower their guard, answer his questions, and to plant post-hypnotic suggestions. Interestingly, it seems that Jane himself is particularly resistant to manipulation by others, this is perhaps telling as to his psychopathology. He is not exactly heartless, but he does seem to have little ego and is not easily manipulated emotionally.

Asceticism

As part of Jane’s self-contempt related to his guilt for his part in his family’s murder, and also for his former life as a charlatan and thief, Jane engages in self-denial. He seems to be loaded with money but spends little on himself and seems to not care about money. His monk-like existence in a dirty storage room at the police station or in a long term motel is bit disingenuous though because what is he really sacrificing? If you don’t care about something it’s easy to forgo. He does take pleasure though, in a particularly childlike ways. He loves nature, but doesn’t seek out that pleasure, but instead takes advantage of the locales of the various cases to get what enjoyment he can from the surroundings. He also enjoys simple foods, tea, ice cream, eggs, etc.

Rudeness

Jane is characteristically rude to most other people. Part of this rudeness is deliberate, when he is probing suspects, where he says disconcerting things to throw people off. Also, he often stares at people, even though it is probably not necessary for him to do this, since in other scenes he will often pick up on a subtle gesture or “tell” without appearing to even glance at the person. If he feels he was mistaken about a suspect- that they really aren’t lying, for example, he often apologizes afterwards. He doesn’t like to be touched himself, but this doesn’t keep him from invading other people’s space and touching them, but only when necessary, although he does use a brief  touch to comfort someone, once in a while.

Vigilante-ism

Patrick is a defiant vigilante, but he accepts personal responsibility for this. He knows what he is doing, he is righteous about it, but he expects to be punished for it. He  is willing to take that risk to avenge his family of course but  also to protect others who are innocent. His actions clearly have caused the deaths of other people, both directly and indirectly, but as long as the victims are in some way guilty themselves, he doesn’t seem to mind. So far there hasn’t been any clear case of innocent “collateral damage” related to his vigilante-ism, but who knows when or if that will occur, and what his response will be. Besides Red John and other serial killers, he has a special disregard for liars and charlatans, probably because of the before mentioned self-hatred regarding his own past.